Heidenhain codes
HeidenhainServo/AxisIntermediate30-120 minutes

230-041A

HEIDENHAIN 230-041A - Position error (axis) too large

Position error (axis) too large

The difference between position encoder and speed encoder measurements exceeds acceptable limits. This indicates a mechanical or encoder-related problem.

Root Cause Summary

This alarm fundamentally indicates that the position controller cannot keep the actual axis position within the monitoring window defined by MP1010. The root cause is either mechanical resistance preventing the axis from following commands, inadequate servo tuning parameters that result in excessive lag, encoder feedback problems that provide incorrect position information, or drive/motor issues that prevent sufficient torque generation.

Safety

  • Refer to Heidenhain service manual
  • Ensure qualified technician performs repairs

Causes and Fixes

  1. 1

    Access machine parameters

    Press MOD key, enter access code, navigate to Machine Parameters > Axis-specific parameters > Select the affected axis

    Document original parameter values before making any changes

  2. 2

    Check MP1010 current value

    Locate MP1010 (Maximum permissible position error) and note the current value in millimeters or degrees. Typical values range from 0.5mm to 2.0mm for linear axes depending on machine type

    Compare this value against similar machines in your facility - consistent values indicate proper baseline

  3. 3

    Monitor actual position error during operation

    Navigate to Test > Position display or use MOD > Position menu to display real-time following error (Schleppfehler). Run typical part program and observe peak following error values

    Peak following error should be 50-70% of MP1010 value during normal operation - if consistently higher, either MP1010 is too tight or servo tuning needs optimization

  4. 4

    Adjust MP1010 if appropriate

    If mechanical and encoder systems are verified good and peak following errors approach or exceed MP1010 during normal operation, incrementally increase MP1010 by 0.2-0.5mm. Test thoroughly and ensure position accuracy remains acceptable

    Increasing MP1010 reduces protection against mechanical failures - only adjust after ruling out mechanical and servo tuning issues

DIY Feasiblemedium confidence

Call a technician if:

  • ·Encoder replacement required
  • ·Mechanical repairs needed
  • ·Servo drive hardware failure suspected

Prevention

  • Regular encoder cleaning and inspection
  • Periodic servo parameter optimization
  • Monitor position error trends during preventive maintenance
  • Maintain proper encoder cable routing and shielding

Common Mistakes

  • Adjusting MP1715 too high to mask mechanical problems
  • Ignoring gradual position error increases
  • Cleaning encoders with inappropriate solvents
  • Changing servo parameters without understanding mechanical system requirements

Seeing Multiple Alarms?

Seeing another alarm with this one? Enter the code.

Get machine-aware diagnosis

AxisMD logs alarms against your actual machines, tracks patterns, and gives AI context your manual doesn't have.

Start free

Was this guide helpful?

Always verify with your machine manual or a certified technician before performing service procedures.